Why the IRS Counts the Assets You Thought Were Off-Limits
By:
Daylan A. Nyarko
Published:
Insights
A business owner owes the IRS $900,000. Her CPA submits an offer in compromise for $60,000, reasoning that her real estate is already subject to a federal tax lien and her accounts are nearly empty. Months later, to her surprise, the offer in compromise is rejected.
A hypothetical, for illustration only.
An offer in compromise generally settles a tax liability for less than the full balance when the IRS believes that collecting the full balance is unrealistic. It is not a negotiation over what a taxpayer is willing to pay; it is a formula. For individuals with substantial assets or business income, offers in compromise are more likely to fail.
How the IRS Measures What It Can Collect
Many offers in compromise are based on doubt that the taxpayer can afford to pay what they owe. The IRS will only accept an offer when the amount is at least equal to the reasonable collection potential. To measure this, the IRS adds the net equity in the taxpayer's assets to a measure of their future income.
If the IRS concludes that the tax can be paid in full before the collection statute expires, the offer in compromise may be rejected. The collection statute expiration date is generally ten years after assessment (IRC Section 6502).
Four Reasons Offers From Sophisticated Taxpayers Fail
Equity that "isn't available" is still counted. Generally, the IRS will value assets at their quick-sale value, roughly 80% of their fair market value, minus any senior loans. For example, if a lender refuses to lend against a property, the IRS will still consider that equity in their calculations.
IRS standards replace actual spending. A household's actual budget is not measured. Instead, the IRS compares national and local allowable expense standards to the taxpayer's future income. This could mean that a household with no excess at the end of each month could still be recorded as having meaningful disposable income.
Spent or transferred assets can still count. Assets transferred or spent after the liability arose could be treated as dissipated and included in the value anyway. This does not apply to necessary living or business expenses.
Compliance is incomplete. All required returns must be filed correctly, and current estimated payments must be made. Additionally, a business with employees must be current on federal tax deposits. After acceptance, the taxpayer needs to remain compliant for five years, or the IRS can default the offer.
If an offer in compromise is being prepared for a business or a substantial personal balance, request a confidential assessment before filing.
When an Offer Is the Wrong Strategy
Many asset-rich taxpayers are better served by contesting the liability through IRS Appeals or the U.S. Tax Court, or by a structured installment agreement. That choice should be made before any forms are filed.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can the IRS reject an offer if my property is already subject to a tax lien?
What happens if I fall out of compliance after an offer is accepted?
Evaluate Your Options Confidentially
Nyar Tax represents business owners, executives, and high-net-worth individuals in IRS collection matters, examinations and appeals, and U.S. Tax Court litigation.
Daylan A. Nyarko handles federal tax matters nationwide from the firm's Austin office. Before an offer is submitted, request a confidential assessment or call 1.888.995.2015.
NYAR TAX
Federal tax advisory and controversy counsel. Austin, Texas. Clients worldwide.
9600 Great Hills Trail, Suite 150W
Austin, Texas 78759
By appointment only
PRACTICE
IRS examination representation
Eggshell and sensitive examinations
Partnership and entity-level adjustments
Offshore reporting and voluntary disclosure
Employment and trust fund matters
IRS Appeals
United States Tax Court litigation
Attorney advertising. This website is for general information only and constitutes attorney advertising in jurisdictions where that designation applies. Nothing on this page is legal, tax, or accounting advice, and none of it should be relied upon as a substitute for advice regarding your specific circumstances.
No attorney-client relationship. Contacting the firm, submitting the inquiry form, or sending email does not create an attorney-client relationship. That relationship is established only by a signed written engagement agreement. Information transmitted before an engagement exists may not be privileged. Please do not send confidential documents until requested.
No guarantee of results. Outcomes depend on the facts of each matter, the developed record, the applicable law, and the discretion of the taxing authority or tribunal involved. The firm does not guarantee any result, does not promise a reduction or elimination of any tax liability, and does not represent that any taxpayer will qualify for any particular resolution or disclosure program. Prior results do not guarantee or predict a similar outcome.
Scope of practice. The firm's practice is limited to federal law, including federal tax matters and federal employer compliance, which includes employment-based immigration filings. State and local tax matters are handled with co-counsel and accounting professionals admitted or licensed in the relevant jurisdiction. The firm's attorney is licensed in Illinois, admitted to the United States Tax Court, and authorized to represent taxpayers before the IRS in all 50 states under Treasury Department Circular 230, and is not licensed in Texas. Federal matters are handled nationally and for clients abroad.
Not affiliated with any government agency. This firm is a private law practice. It is not the Internal Revenue Service, is not affiliated with, endorsed by, or acting on behalf of the IRS, the United States Department of the Treasury, the Department of Justice, the Department of Labor, U.S. Citizenship and Immigration Services, or any state taxing authority, and uses no government seal, logo, or insignia.
Responsible attorney: Daylan A. Nyarko. Principal office (by appointment only): 9600 Great Hills Trail, Suite 150W, Austin, Texas 78759.
© 2026 Nyar Tax. All rights reserved.