What You Say to an IRS Auditor Stays on the Record
By:
Daylan A. Nyarko
Published:
Insights
A founder with an MBA prepares for her first audit the way she prepares for a board meeting. She reads the rules thoroughly and uses an AI tool to summarize her position. She’s confident and well informed. When the examiner asks about $400,000 moved between her company and personal account, she answers easily: “Loans, mostly.” The examiner immediately writes the word “mostly” in his notes.
A hypothetical, for illustration only.
Sophistication Is Not the Same as Protection
Many taxpayers assume that they can handle an audit meeting, and most audits proceed smoothly, with professional examiners working hard to complete a difficult job. However, an examination is not a dialogue between equals. The examiner chooses what questions need to be asked and how the answers are recorded. The taxpayer's answers during the examination follow the file to IRS Appeals and, in some cases, the U.S. Tax Court.
While having a strong understanding of finances, or reading through an AI summary, can help to explain the rules of an audit meeting, it cannot predict the examiner's questions, show how your answer will be read, or help when an offhand explanation becomes an admission.
Once Said, It Cannot Be Unsaid
Inconsistent or speculative answers shared in an audit meeting are difficult to correct, and later explanations are weighed against the first.
When it comes to unreported income or penalties, an earlier statement could determine whether the IRS views a discrepancy as an error or a serious offense.
The Law Gives You a Buffer. Use It.
A taxpayer has a right to representation during an IRS audit interview (under IRC Section 7521). This representation may be an attorney, CPA, or enrolled agent.
During an interview, if the taxpayer asks to consult a representative, the meeting is generally suspended. The Taxpayer Bill of Rights, codified in IRC Section 7803(a)(3), includes the right to retain representation.
Throughout the examination, counsel manages how it proceeds: asking that questions come in writing through information document requests, giving responses that are complete without volunteering more, and keeping a documented record. If an examination becomes difficult, counsel can escalate it appropriately to a group manager, the Taxpayer Advocate Service, or Appeals.
If your first audit meeting is approaching, request a confidential assessment before speaking with the examiner.
When to Involve Counsel
Involve counsel when:
The examiner asks to interview you or your executives directly.
Questions are asked about specific transfers, deposits, or transactions.
The examination has expanded to include more years or new issues.
An examiner's requests or tone have become difficult to navigate.
Frequently Asked Questions
Do I have to meet with the IRS auditor myself?
Can my CPA handle the audit instead?
Discuss Your Examination Confidentially
Nyar Tax represents business owners, executives, and high-net-worth individuals in IRS examinations, appeals, and U.S. Tax Court litigation.
Daylan A. Nyarko handles federal tax matters nationwide from the firm's Austin office. Before the next conversation with the examiner, request a confidential assessment, or call 1.888.995.2015.
NYAR TAX
Federal tax advisory and controversy counsel. Austin, Texas. Clients worldwide.
9600 Great Hills Trail, Suite 150W
Austin, Texas 78759
By appointment only
PRACTICE
IRS examination representation
Eggshell and sensitive examinations
Partnership and entity-level adjustments
Offshore reporting and voluntary disclosure
Employment and trust fund matters
IRS Appeals
United States Tax Court litigation
Attorney advertising. This website is for general information only and constitutes attorney advertising in jurisdictions where that designation applies. Nothing on this page is legal, tax, or accounting advice, and none of it should be relied upon as a substitute for advice regarding your specific circumstances.
No attorney-client relationship. Contacting the firm, submitting the inquiry form, or sending email does not create an attorney-client relationship. That relationship is established only by a signed written engagement agreement. Information transmitted before an engagement exists may not be privileged. Please do not send confidential documents until requested.
No guarantee of results. Outcomes depend on the facts of each matter, the developed record, the applicable law, and the discretion of the taxing authority or tribunal involved. The firm does not guarantee any result, does not promise a reduction or elimination of any tax liability, and does not represent that any taxpayer will qualify for any particular resolution or disclosure program. Prior results do not guarantee or predict a similar outcome.
Scope of practice. The firm's practice is limited to federal law, including federal tax matters and federal employer compliance, which includes employment-based immigration filings. State and local tax matters are handled with co-counsel and accounting professionals admitted or licensed in the relevant jurisdiction. The firm's attorney is licensed in Illinois, admitted to the United States Tax Court, and authorized to represent taxpayers before the IRS in all 50 states under Treasury Department Circular 230, and is not licensed in Texas. Federal matters are handled nationally and for clients abroad.
Not affiliated with any government agency. This firm is a private law practice. It is not the Internal Revenue Service, is not affiliated with, endorsed by, or acting on behalf of the IRS, the United States Department of the Treasury, the Department of Justice, the Department of Labor, U.S. Citizenship and Immigration Services, or any state taxing authority, and uses no government seal, logo, or insignia.
Responsible attorney: Daylan A. Nyarko. Principal office (by appointment only): 9600 Great Hills Trail, Suite 150W, Austin, Texas 78759.
© 2026 Nyar Tax. All rights reserved.